f7220e85fd build: update RapidCheck Makefile (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
- update RapidCheck to the latest commit on master
- install only the extras needed by Bitcoin Core, e.g. ENABLE_BOOST_TEST instead of INSTALL_ALL_EXTRAS
- remove cmake warning by providing `-B` arg:
```
CMake Warning:
No source or binary directory provided. Both will be assumed to be the
same as the current working directory, but note that this warning will
become a fatal error in future CMake releases.
```
Tested with `cd depends && make RAPIDCHECK=1` on Linux Debian.
ACKs for top commit:
fanquake:
ACK f7220e85fd - Tested building using depends. `ENABLE_BOOST_TEST` instead of `INSTALL_ALL_EXTRAS` seems fine.
Tree-SHA512: 8033aa25014a87125cd0aa0885a892649039ef888688f4a855d23af21a350792a4081b181b8222ed293b5070dff39c438e9c3f80294eda0c931076a8153403ea
b9ee63c71b Make descriptor test deterministic (David Reikher)
Pull request description:
This is an improvement to a test, inspired by #14343 - removing non determinism from a test.
The test `descriptor_test` is non-deterministic, as it relies on the `MaybeUseHInsteadOfApostrophy` function which randomly either swaps all apostrophes with 'h' or doesn't at all in a descriptor. This fix makes both cases always run, if an apostrophe is found in a test descriptor.
This does not reduce test coverage but removes the non-determinism.
Additionally, the `MaybeUseHInsteadOfApostrophy` function removed the checksum if found at the end of a descriptor when the apostrophes are swapped by 'h's, since after being swapped the checksum is no longer correct. I instead added re-calculation of the checksum using the `DescriptorChecksum` function, which adds coverage for the case of a descriptors having 'h's instead of apostrophes and a checksum. This was previously lacking.
To achieve this I had to move `DescriptorChecksum` and `PolyMod` out of the anonymous namespace in descriptor.cpp to make `DescriptorChecksum` accessible in descriptor_tests.cpp.
All tests complete successfully (functional as well as unit tests).
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
Code Review ACK b9ee63c71b
Tree-SHA512: 992c73a6644a07bfe7c72301ee2666f3c4845a012aaedd7a099a05cea8bdac84fa8280b28e44a7856260c00c0be1a6f1b6768f5694c2a22edf4c489e53fec424
faebf62714 rpc: Use Join helper in rpc/util (MarcoFalke)
fa8cd6f9c1 util: Add Join helper to join a list of strings (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
We have a lot of enumerations in the code and sometimes those enumerations need to be mentioned in the RPC or command line documentation. Previously, each caller would have a couple of lines inline to join the strings or the joined string is hardcoded in the documentation. A helper to join strings would make code such as https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/16629#discussion_r315852446 less verbose and easier to read.
Also, warnings commonly accumulate in complex RPCs, since a warning doesn't lead to an early return. A helper to join those warnings would make code such as https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/16394/files#r309324997 less verbose and easier to read.
ACKs for top commit:
practicalswift:
ACK faebf62714
Tree-SHA512: 80f2db86a05c63b686f510585c1c631250271a8958fd71fafaac91559ffd2ec25d609bf7d53412ba27f87eff5893ac9dd9c2f296fc0c73581556e1d6a734a36f
153d9dd9ac refactor: replace qLowerBound & qUpperBound with std:: upper_bound & lower_bound (fanquake)
59373e3e94 refactor: replace qSort with std::sort (fanquake)
fea33cbbdf refactor: replace qStableSort with std::stable_sort (fanquake)
Pull request description:
`qStablesort`, `qSort`, `qLowerBound` and `qUpperBound` have been marked as obsolete since at least Qt 5.9: [Obsolete Members for QtAlgorithms](https://doc.qt.io/qt-5.9/qtalgorithms-obsolete.html).
This pull request replaces their usage with the suggested `std::` replacements.
This also removes some warning spam when compiling against newer Qt (5.13.0 via brew):
```bash
CXX qt/libbitcoinqt_a-walletcontroller.o
qt/transactiontablemodel.cpp:96:52: warning: 'qLowerBound<QList<TransactionRecord>::iterator, uint256, TxLessThan>' is deprecated: Use std::lower_bound [-Wdeprecated-declarations]
QList<TransactionRecord>::iterator lower = qLowerBound(
qt/transactiontablemodel.cpp:98:52: warning: 'qUpperBound<QList<TransactionRecord>::iterator, uint256, TxLessThan>' is deprecated: Use std::upper_bound [-Wdeprecated-declarations]
QList<TransactionRecord>::iterator upper = qUpperBound(
```
```bash
CXX qt/libbitcoinqt_a-moc_walletcontroller.o
qt/bantablemodel.cpp:64:13: warning: 'qStableSort<QList<CCombinedBan>::iterator, BannedNodeLessThan>' is deprecated: Use std::stable_sort [-Wdeprecated-declarations]
qStableSort(cachedBanlist.begin(), cachedBanlist.end(), BannedNodeLessThan(sortColumn, sortOrder));
```
```bash
CXX qt/libbitcoinqt_a-sendcoinsentry.o
qt/recentrequeststablemodel.cpp:205:5: warning: 'qSort<QList<RecentRequestEntry>::iterator, RecentRequestEntryLessThan>' is deprecated: Use std::sort [-Wdeprecated-declarations]
qSort(list.begin(), list.end(), RecentRequestEntryLessThan(column, order));
```
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 153d9dd9ac
promag:
ACK 153d9dd9ac.
jonasschnelli:
utACK 153d9dd9ac
Tree-SHA512: 22f7290ed798ce8b0f5f313405377845d4c8e48dc8687be7464e27fff53363b451a40e9e18910a8c3b4b9d4dcc236a366c92e7d171fcb8576c48f149a1886c26
6011c9d72d QA: fix rpc_setban.py race (Jonas Schnelli)
Pull request description:
The new `rpc_setban.py` test failes regularly on CIs due to a race between injecting the ban and testing the log "on the other side".
The problem is, that the test immediately after the `addnode` command on node0 checks for the `dropped (banned)` entry on node1 (without giving some time).
Adding a 2 seconds sleep seems to solve the race (I guess there is no better event-driven delay).
Example of a failed test: https://bitcoinbuilds.org/index.php?ansilog=bf743910-103f-4b54-9a97-960c471061bd.log#l2906
Top commit has no ACKs.
Tree-SHA512: 680f8ea3e5ddb07e93f824f1aeff4a459e25e6c14715a39fc7670e50506d7cf25925348672c5c2d8ba3e1243ccf5effbc2456bcd094fb96868349f8d26e008f1
2dbfb37b40 Fix Char as Bool in interfaces (Jeremy Rubin)
Pull request description:
In a few places in src/wallet/wallet.h, we use a char when semantically we want a bool.
This is kind of an issue because it means we can unserialize the same transaction with different fFromMe flags (as differing chars) and evaluate the following section in wallet/wallet.cpp
```c++
if (wtxIn.fFromMe && wtxIn.fFromMe != wtx.fFromMe)
{
wtx.fFromMe = wtxIn.fFromMe;
fUpdated = true;
}
```
incorrectly (triggering an fUpdated where both fFromMe values represent true, via different chars).
I don't think this is a vulnerability, but it's just a little messy and unsemantic, and could lead to issues with stored wtxIns not being findable in a map by their hash.
The serialize/unserialize code for bool internally uses a char, so it should be safe to make this substitution.
NOTE: Technically, this is a behavior change -- I haven't checked too closely that nowhere is depending on storing information in this char. Theoretically, this could break something because after this change a tx unserialized with such a char would preserve it's value, but now it is converted to a ~true~ canonical bool.
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
Code review ACK 2dbfb37b40
meshcollider:
Code review ACK 2dbfb37b40
Tree-SHA512: 8c0dc9cf672aa2276c694facbf50febe7456eaa8bf2bd2504f81a61052264b8b30cdb5326e1936893adc3d33504667aee3c7e207a194c71d87b3e7b5fe199c9d
Changed MaybeUseHInsteadOfApostrophy to UseHInsteadOfApostrophe.
This function now always replaces apostrophes with 'h'.
The original Check function was renamed to DoCheck and it's
called with an additional parameter which tells it to either
leave the prv and pub arguments as is or replace the apostrophes
with 'h'. The test runs with apostrophes replaced in prv only,
pub only, prv and pub and without replacement at all. Replacement
of apostrophes in a descriptor and then running DoCheck is conditional
on whether apostrophes are found in that descriptor.
Additionally, instead of dropping the checksum recalculate it
after replacing apostrophes with 'h' in the function UseHInsteadOfApostrophe
using the GetDescriptorChecksum function. That way, this also
introduces an indirect unit test to GetDescriptoChecksum.
c84ff23c6d build: ignore macOS make deploy artefacts & add them to clean-local (fanquake)
Pull request description:
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK c84ff23c6d, tested on Linux Mint 19.2:
dongcarl:
ACK c84ff23c6d
Tree-SHA512: 5a6525a5e433a7279807cc02d3f47bb7f4bd5da8142a945b21d3bfa71938cac823569b34b071e21525a817a187fb02a562bb1c5a9761e2019a2b0900a51a8315
17d178fb94 doc: add release-notes for getmempoolentry weight field addition (fanquake)
9c9cc2bd20 qa: Add RPC tests for weight in mempool entry (Daniel Edgecumbe)
54aaa7883c RPC: add weight to mempool entry output (Daniel Edgecumbe)
Pull request description:
Rebase of #14649 (which itself was a rebase of #11256).
Squash the two test related commits, and swapped out `size` usage for `vsize`.
Added a commit with release notes.
ACKs for top commit:
emilengler:
Concept ACK 17d178f
instagibbs:
utACK 17d178fb94
meshcollider:
utACK 17d178fb94
Tree-SHA512: 1d354c9837e0ad0afa40325de9329b9e62688d5eab4d9e1cf9b46d8ae29d08f42d903ab37a41751c2ea8f9034231b21095881b1f5d911cb542b8b06bc85dc7cd
The bitcoin user needs read access to the configuration file, but write
access is not needed. It is not considered best practice to make
configuration directories and files owned by the services reading them.
Rather than making the config dir world-readable, which potentially
leaks RPC credentials, the group of the directory is changed to the one
the service is executed as.
The phrasing seemed to indicate that the options specified in
ExecStart= could not be specified in the config file, necessitating
their inclusion in the service file. However, the options in the
config file simply get overridden by any specified in ExecStart=.
b6e9ff8996 build: Remove src/obj directory from repository (Wladimir J. van der Laan)
Pull request description:
This directory is automatically created by the build process (in the build target directory, see #16588) and doesn't need to be in the repository nor in the tarballs.
Move associated ignore directive to top-level `.gitignore` file.
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
Concept ACK b6e9ff8996
Tree-SHA512: 5f3f5a0e8f19ecf925eb16cab327c3023b8512731bbaad5875828da7a25fdda1b77f6fbd06c002a383913627dc9b552f09ad27c57bcf0cb020ed3b1f506e5fef
8616c81f08 doc: initial RapidCheck property-based testing documentation (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
This commit proposes documentation that would have been helpful to me when setting up RapidCheck to work correctly with Bitcoin Core. I tested these instructions repeatedly with Linux (Debian 4.19 / GCC 8.3) and macOS (10.14.6 / AppleClang 10).
The markdown version can be seen at https://github.com/jonatack/bitcoin/blob/rapidcheck-documentation/doc/rapidcheck.md.
ACKs for top commit:
fanquake:
ACK 8616c81f08 - Thanks for updating.
Tree-SHA512: 9c2a65f0eb99f59e9adfea82855f217727a8a9d30618c1c0bdd2a73ae9c1ee61bc7efd59fc8703a666d182ad4220e22d6034ac3109311e6573dad00dfa4b06ea
ffea41f530 Enable all tests in feature_config_args.py (Hennadii Stepanov)
66f5c17f8a Use CheckDataDirOption() for code uniformity (Hennadii Stepanov)
7e33a18a34 Fix datadir handling in bitcoin-cli (Hennadii Stepanov)
b28dada374 Fix datadir handling in bitcoin-qt (Hennadii Stepanov)
50824093bb Fix datadir handling in bitcoind (Hennadii Stepanov)
740d41ce9f Add CheckDataDirOption() function (Hennadii Stepanov)
c1f325126c Return absolute path early in AbsPathForConfigVal (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
Fix#15240, see: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/15240#issuecomment-487353760Fix#15745
Fix broken `feature_config_args.py` tests (disabled by MarcoFalke@fabe28a0cdcfa13e0e595a0905e3642a960d3077). All test are enabled now.
This PR is alternative to #13621.
User's `$HOME` directory is not touched unnecessarily now.
~To make reviewing easier only `bitcoind` code is modified (neither `bitcoin-cli` nor `bitcoin-qt`).~
Refs:
- https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/15745#issuecomment-479852569 by **laanwj**
- #16220
Top commit has no ACKs.
Tree-SHA512: 4a4cda10e0b67c8f374da0c9567003d2b566d948e7f8550fe246868b5794c15010e88ea206009480b9cd2f737f310a15e984f920730448f99a895893bed351df
fa21737ba7 ci: Add environment files for all settings (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
This moves all environment settings from travis to files in the ci folder. Now, it is possible to easily run each travis configuration with a single command.
Top commit has no ACKs.
Tree-SHA512: 989c6b62eb3839eb1fa5461e986496e9660167e2438a789c7588a6fee4f9c37b332782c010fe5c7de8f606bcf98dffb2481d2777cbce88f87cc9f0c42fb2d7fc
20ea9ef6ce [doc] mention whitelist is inbound, and applies to blocksonly (Sjors Provoost)
Pull request description:
* `-whitelist` only impacts inbound nodes (see #9923). This is obvious in the context of allowing those nodes to connect to you, but there are additional whitelist features where this is less obvious, such as mempool relay behavior.
* `whitelistrelay` (on by default) explains that `-blocksonly` makes an exception for transactions from whitelisted nodes, but it wasn't documented (nor obvious imo) the other way around. See also https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/15984#issuecomment-490645552
Top commit has no ACKs.
Tree-SHA512: 03e363a5da5d81ad147d1c7e38bf11114df8bb89bdd66fb551520b25f810efa886ec6e649d3b435c4935e0ae4f39bb718bc7bb5778b9de6aa0b71e970a431af8
b168dd30cf Bugfix: QA: Run tests with UPnP disabled (Luke Dashjr)
Pull request description:
This replaces #16560 by adding `upnp=0` to `bitcoin.conf` rather than passing it to nodes.
> Needed for builds configured with --enable-upnp-default
You can test this change using:
```bash
./configure --enable-upnp-default && make -j6 && test/functional/test_runner.py feature_config_args.py
```
on master the test will fail without this change.
ACKs for top commit:
practicalswift:
ACK b168dd30cf -- diff looks correct
Tree-SHA512: e639dd480dda2cffa19a679018c4bd7e4bd4d0f5e3001d6b407b833e3c166bde98b201063e267b8e45f8a20b0d53ec8bc028bec806b2357f9a7ba314cc4e2d07
3b05f0f70f Reformat p2p_permissions.py (nicolas.dorier)
ce7eac3cb0 [Fix] The default whitelistrelay should be true (nicolas.dorier)
Pull request description:
I thought `whitelistrelay` default was `false` when it is `true`.
The root of the issue come from the fact that all references to `DEFAULT_` are not in the scope of this file, so hard coding of default values are used everywhere in `net.cpp`. I think that in a separate PR we should fix that more fundamentally everywhere.
ACKs for top commit:
promag:
ACK 3b05f0f70f.
Sjors:
re-ACK 3b05f0f70f
Tree-SHA512: f4a75f986fa2adf1a5f1c91605e0d261f7ac5ac8535fb05437d83b8392dbcf5cc1a47d755adcf8ad8dc67a88de28060187200fd3ce06545261a5c7ec0fea831a
fa0119af22 doc: Refer in rpcbind doc to the manpage (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
The help was outdated, so refer to the updated manpage instead.
* closes#14740
* closes#9272
ACKs for top commit:
emilengler:
Concept ACK fa0119a
laanwj:
ACK fa0119af22
fanquake:
ACK fa0119af22
Tree-SHA512: 9836e4f31ece7acae334b47e3104b4595d0d1c1977af386a9463faf49aea9de3ab1c1dc3de248d0ee09e3b13693eaf6902dc82d277062e1bb1980b1117236fbb
dc1bc1c503 doc: Add ZMQ dependencies to Fedora build (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
Without `zeromq-devel` package on Fedora 30:
```
$ ./configure | grep zmq
configure: WARNING: libzmq version 4.x or greater not found, disabling
with zmq = no
```
With installed `zeromq-devel`:
```
$ ./configure | grep zmq
with zmq = yes
```
Also this PR improves style in the `miniupnpc` related paragraphs.
ACKs for top commit:
emilengler:
Concept ACK dc1bc1c
practicalswift:
ACK dc1bc1c503 -- diff looks correct
fanquake:
ACK dc1bc1c503 - tested in a Fedora 30 Docker container. Other changes match the Ubuntu & Debian docs above.
Tree-SHA512: 89b083a6256e8d0bcb9f0b193af84bc680843fdbb4a3e8871086477875250ad0ae214ce08797fc70c0cb04a2969632840c805a2a10a433763ee31cd1aa793bac
787c9ec0c3 Additional tests for other failure cases (Andrew Chow)
6e1ae58298 Check error messages in descriptor tests (Andrew Chow)
625534d7b1 Give more errors for specific failure conditions (Andrew Chow)
c325f619dd Return an error from descriptor Parse that gives more information about what failed (Andrew Chow)
Pull request description:
Because it's nigh impossible to figure out what is wrong with a descriptor otherwise.
ACKs for top commit:
Sjors:
ACK 787c9ec
meshcollider:
Code review ACK 787c9ec0c3
Tree-SHA512: 07c5deff127fd65507b96df2e4608b4f918e0cbd20b3b45b9ab5a05c2985a6efa9832079cf1e7f504305bfbb861019e93b96cc1574dd63b2ff0756b5928ece20
a6c1fc3cd9 build: echo prop tests status during build (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
Enable users to see if the prop tests are enabled during the build. This can be particularly helpful as property-based tests are silently auto-enabled by default if librapidcheck is found.
Sample build output:
```
Options used to compile and link:
with wallet = yes
with gui / qt = yes
with bip70 = yes
with qr = yes
with zmq = yes
with test = yes
with prop = yes <--- new
with fuzz = no
with bench = no
```
ACKs for top commit:
fanquake:
ACK a6c1fc3cd9 - Thanks. Tested `./configure` with and without rapidcheck available.
Tree-SHA512: 460f3b83ee2a03e6dcc53bc326ac210d2484895e11766be117920fbc6fa78cdbcd4267cbceda9447c2f5fa5a7f218865ccc929ac6319308e397c0a5603571ecd
